Battle of the Peach Palettes - Who Is The Real Winner?

Marisa Robinson Beauty Peach Palettes

There is nothing I love more this spring than a pretty peach eyeshadow palette. I love the way peachy, pink shades make my eyes pop and how it creates a fun and fresh look.

But I didn't just stop at one peach palette this season and have noticed some considerable differences which I am going to share with you in this blog post.

Prepare for the Battle of the Peach Palettes!
 

Too Faced 'Sweet Peach' Palette

Marisa Robinson Beauty Peach Palettes Too Faced

$70AUD from Mecca
Cruelty Free: Yes
This palette is not Vegan Friendly however TF do have a selection of VF products in their range.
This was the first peach palette I added to my collection along with their 'Sweet Peach Glow' Face Palette and not only do I love the shades but the sweet peach scent you smell whenever you open the palette is beautiful! The shades are beautifully pigmented especially the shimmers which add a really beautiful glow to any eye look.

PROS
- Buttery and pigmented shimmer shadows
- Smells like peaches

CONS
- Matte shadows aren't as pigmented as I like
- I would prefer more matte 'peachy' shadows
(I guess that is why they released the new peach matte palette!)
 

Too Faced 'Sweet Peach Palette' Swatches

Marisa Robinson Beauty Peach Palettes Too Faced Sweet Peach Palette Swatches

From left to right: Summer Yum, Candied Peach, Just Peachy, Luscious, Nectar, White Peach

 

BYS Cosmetics 'PEACH' Palette

Marisa Robinson Beauty Peach Palettes BYS Peach Palette

$16.95AUD from K-Mart
Cruelty Free: Yes
As soon as I saw this palette popping up all over Insta I knew I had to have it! Not only is it available at Kmart (one of my fave places to shop especially for Insta decor!) but with a price tag of only $16.95 it is super affordable. This palette contains 12 matte and metallic shadows and includes two dual ended applicators and mirror. This palette has really blown me away in terms of pigmentation and quality!

PROS
- Affordable and available from Kmart
- Contains the perfect peach shades
- Shimmer shades are super pigmented with intense shine pay off

CONS
- Some of the shimmer shadows can be a little chalky but blend out nicely
- I wish there was more matte shades in the palette
 

BYS Cosmetics 'PEACH' Palette Swatches

Marisa Robinson Beauty Peach Palettes BYS Peach Palette Swatches

From left to right: Enticing, Peachy, Pamper, Slay, Dazzling, Dainty

 

Karity Cosmetics 'Just Peachy' Palette

Marisa Robinson Beauty Peach Palettes Karity Just Peachy Palette

$25USD > $32AUD + Shipping
Cruelty Free: Yes
Vegan Friendly
I first saw Nikki Tutorials using this palette on her Snapchat and loved the look she created so I had to try it for myself and I definitely wasn't disappointed. This palette contains a combination of matte and shimmer shadows in beautiful pink, peach, orange and brown shades.

PROS
- The shadows blend out beautifully
- The shimmer shadows are smooth and buttery
- I love the bold orange shade and the colours complement each other beautifully.

CONS
- I wish there was more matte shades in the palette
 

Karity Cosmetics 'Just Peachy' Palette Swatches

Marisa Robinson Beauty Peach Palettes Karity Just Peachy Palette Swatches

From left to right: Organic, Princess, Creamy, Cobbler, Glow Up and Freshly Picked

 

Marisa Robinson Beauty Peach Palette Swatches

Top to Bottom: BYS 'Peach' Palette', Too Faced 'Sweet Peach' Palette + Karity 'Just Peachy' Palette


THE VERDICT
It is honestly so hard to choose a favourite as I feel all the palettes are different to each other in terms of the shades and the colour pay off.

But if I had to choose only one Peach Palette out of the three above I would definitely have to say the BYS 'Peach' Palette. This came as a complete surprise to me but the peachy shades in this palette are exactly what I was looking for. They are perfectly pigmented (especially the shimmers which are quite intense especially when packed on), blend beautifully and the palette is super affordable.

The Karity 'Just Peachy' palette would come second as I am obsessed with the buttery shimmers and love how pigmented both the matte and shimmer shades are.

The Too Faced 'Sweet Peach' palette would come a close third. I still love this palette, especially the scent, but there just aren't as many peachy shades in this palette as I was hoping for.

Look created using the Karity 'Just Peachy' palette.


What is your favourite peach palette?

x